Skip to content
O&M

Where to stay

Where to Stay

Three options, all bookable now. The island is small and September weekends go quickly.

Watercolour map of Fire Island, with the Great South Bay and the Bay Shore ferry terminal along the top and the Atlantic along the bottom. Ocean Beach, Seaview and Ocean Bay Park run left to right along the island, with the weekend's venues, ferry terminals and places to stay numbered one to eleven and listed in a legend beneath. Walking and cycling times are marked along the shore: one minute from the Ocean Beach ferry to Maguire's and The Palms, twelve minutes on foot or four by bike from Seaview to Ocean Beach, and twenty-five minutes on foot or seven by bike from Ocean Bay Park.
Scroll sideways to explore the island.

Before you choose

Both evenings are in Ocean Beach, a minute from the ferry. Staying there means you walk to everything.

Seaview
12 min walk · 4 min by bike
Ocean Bay Park
25 min walk · 7 min by bike

Ocean Beach

The Palms Hotel

In town. Walk to both venues and the ferry.

A minute from the ferry, the welcome party and the reception.

Our block
Friday 17 – Sunday 19 September 2027
Promo code
FIWed091827
Held until
4 July 2027
Call, don't click
The Palms has several buildings around Ocean Beach. Phone them and they will place your party together — booking online, you take what you get.
Included
Bikes, and help with luggage at the ferry.
Longer stays
One night or both online. For extra nights, call.
Worth knowing
A straightforward island hotel — handy rather than fancy.
Book online631-583-8870info@palmshotelfireisland.com

Ocean Bay Park

Seashore Condo Motel

One village east. Roomier, and worth the walk.

25 minutes on foot from Ocean Beach, or 7 minutes by bike.

Our block
None yet — we will update this page in December 2026.
Booking
Book with them directly, any time.
Book online631-583-5860info@seashorecondomotel.com

Across the island

Houses & rentals

Best if you are coming as a group.

Our list
We have put together a few places we like the look of across the three villages. A starting point, not an endorsement — we have not stayed in any of them.
Worth knowing
Splitting a house is usually cheaper and nicer than rooms.
Our Airbnb recommendations
Getting thereThe weekend